Commentator asks whether 2026 new gTLD round will benefit internet users
in plain words
ICANN is running a new round where companies can apply to create new website endings, such as new kinds of web addresses. An internet governance expert asks whether more endings actually help ordinary people. He points to few applications for names in non-Latin scripts and to problems with using them.
Full summary
Alfredo Calderon, dean of the Virtual School of Internet Governance, argues in a CircleID An online publishing platform on internet infrastructure and domain policy, launched in 2002. Full definition of CircleID blog post that the success of ICANN Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers The nonprofit that coordinates the global DNS and gTLD policy. Full definition of ICANN’s 2026 New gTLD generic top-level domain A top-level domain not tied to a country, run under ICANN contracts. Full definition of gTLD Round should be judged by its benefit to people who use the internet, not by the number of applications or approvals. He writes from his perspective as an individual user and an active member of the At-Large community.
The post cites 1,615 applications reported on Reveal Day The day ICANN publishes who applied for which new gTLD strings. Full definition of Reveal Day. Calderon says counts of applications, approved top-level domains and registration Obtaining the right to use a domain name for a set period. Full definition of registration show the program’s reach and commercial interest, but do not show whether ordinary users are better off. He raises practical questions, such as whether a small business can afford to keep a new domain without unexpected renewal Paying to extend a domain registration for more time. Full definition of renewal costs, and whether a person can use a domain in their own language for a website, online services and email.
On multilingual inclusion, Calderon says ICANN’s October 2026 application data shows only 21 applications for Internationalized Domain Names (IDN Internationalized Domain Name A domain name written in local scripts or with accented letters. Full definition of IDN). He says application numbers alone cannot explain why, but they raise questions about accessibility for linguistic communities. He also says a valid IDN does not guarantee it works in practice, and that software that fails to recognize, validate, store or display such names causes problems. He says ICANN’s 2026 reporting acknowledges progress on Universal Acceptance The goal that every valid domain name and email address works in all software. Full definition of Universal Acceptance while important gaps remain, and that closing them requires cooperation from software developers, technology companies and service providers.
Calderon links these points to the 2012 round The first round of ICANN's New gTLD Program, which opened for applications in 2012. Full definition of 2012 round. He cites the Competition, Consumer Trust, and Consumer Choice (CCT) Review, completed in 2018, which found evidence that the program increased competition and consumer choice. The same review identified limits in the information available to assess competition, safeguards, consumer trust and geographic representation. Calderon says he finds this relevant today and warns against entering another round without a clear strategy for collecting such information.